top of page
3PP AirBnB Mgmt (No Background Shadow) - Hi Res 1_edited.png

Vacation Rental Market Data Topsail: 7 Numbers Owners Need

Writer: Eric McCarty
Eric McCarty
Nov 7
9 min read
Clean beach cottage living room on Topsail Island, a useful look at vacation rental market data Topsail owners can use
First-morning view of a Topsail Island rental, ready for the next guest.

Vacation rental market data Topsail Island owners can rely on shows a seasonal, house-heavy market. Average annual revenue per listing runs from $34,444 to $42,499 across the three towns. Occupancy sits in the mid to high thirties. At 3 Putt Properties, LLC, we manage short-term rentals in Surf City and across coastal North Carolina, and the seven numbers below are the ones we use to size up a Topsail property in 2026.


Key Takeaways


  • Topsail Island had 1,894 active short-term rental listings across Surf City, Topsail Beach, and North Topsail Beach for June 2025 through May 2026, according to AirROI data.

  • Occupancy averages in the mid to high thirties in all three towns, so a typical listing leaves most of the calendar unbooked.

  • Summer months bring roughly four times the monthly revenue of the winter months in Topsail Beach, with July as the peak.

  • Listing supply grew 51.8% to 63.0% year over year, outpacing revenue-per-listing growth of 19.6% to 50.5%.

  • Topsail Beach guests book about 81 days ahead for 5.6-night stays, mostly in houses that sleep eight or more.

  • Market averages are gross revenue; owner profit depends on management fees, cleaning, insurance, taxes, and platform charges.


Topsail Island is a 26-mile barrier island split into three rental markets: Surf City, Topsail Beach, and North Topsail Beach. Owners searching for market data usually want one thing, a defensible estimate of what a house will earn. The trouble is that published figures use different windows and definitions, so a number from one report rarely matches another.


This guide uses AirROI trailing-12-month data for June 2025 through May 2026 as its backbone. Other figures appear with their own windows labeled. Every revenue figure is gross booking income, before fees, cleaning, insurance, and taxes.


If you own from out of state, are weighing a purchase, or are tired of guessing at rates, work through the seven numbers in order. Each one answers a question we hear from Topsail owners before they set a price or sign a management agreement.


1. How Many Short-Term Rentals Operate on Topsail Island?


Active listing count is the number of short-term rentals taking bookings during a reporting window, and it defines the competitive field you enter. For June 2025 through May 2026, AirROI data counts 1,894 active listings across Topsail Island: 733 in Surf City, 186 in Topsail Beach, and 975 in North Topsail Beach.


The three towns sit in two counties. Surf City and Topsail Beach are in Pender County, while North Topsail Beach is in Onslow County. That split affects permits and lodging tax, covered later in this guide.


Management share matters too. In Topsail Beach, 62.9% of listings were professionally managed, so a self-managed owner competes against operators with pricing software and round-the-clock guest messaging. The table below is the town-by-town snapshot; later sections refer back to it instead of repeating every figure.


Metric (June 2025 to May 2026)

Surf City

Topsail Beach

North Topsail Beach

Active listings

733

186

975

Occupancy

37.7%

35.9%

37.6%

Average daily rate

$420

$440

$462

Average annual revenue per listing

$41,851

$34,444

$42,499

Year-over-year revenue per listing

+19.6%

+25.8%

+50.5%

Year-over-year listing supply

+51.8%

+61.7%

+63.0%


2. What Occupancy Rate Do Topsail Island Rentals Reach?


Occupancy rate is the share of available nights a listing is booked, and on Topsail Island it sits in the mid to high thirties. The three towns land within two points of each other, with Topsail Beach lowest at 35.9%. AirROI's separate island-wide page reports 38%, which fits the same range.


Selected top performers look very different. Those listings show 89% occupancy in July and 79% in June.


Treat that sample as a ceiling. Whole-market averages include newer listings with weaker photos. They also include calendars blocked for owner use. The gap between the average and the top sample usually traces back to calendar strategy and listing quality, plus review score.


We underwrite with the market average and treat top-sample months as upside. An owner who budgets on July's 89% will be disappointed by January.


Topsail Island beach houses and vacation rental market data
A wide sandy beach on a barrier island at golden hour with rows of two-story beach houses on pilings behind the dunes

3. What Nightly Rate Do Topsail Rentals Earn?


Average daily rate, or ADR, is the average price paid per booked night, which leaves out nights nobody booked. Across Topsail Island, ADR runs from $420 in Surf City to $462 in North Topsail Beach, with Topsail Beach at $440. Because most Topsail stock is large houses, those figures reflect whole-home pricing for groups rather than per-room rates.


ADR alone can mislead. A $440 rate on 36% occupancy leaves most of the calendar empty, so revenue per available night (RevPAR) is the better yardstick. A high headline rate does not help if the house sits unbooked through March.


Pricing method closes part of that gap. AvantStay reports that dynamic pricing boosts vacation rental revenue by 10% to 40% annually in 2026, and BoringHost puts the most common range at 20% to 30%. At 3 Putt Properties, LLC, our revenue management approach pairs pricing software with hands-on review of gap nights and shoulder-season rates. If you want the mechanics, read how dynamic pricing for vacation rentals works.


4. How Much Gross Revenue Does a Topsail Rental Generate?


Gross annual revenue per listing is total booking income before any owner expense, and it varies by town. In the June 2025 to May 2026 window, Topsail Beach had the lowest average and North Topsail Beach the highest (see the snapshot table). AirROI's island-wide page puts the average home at $48,094, and its town comparison shows North Topsail Beach at $50,047 against $38,025 in Topsail Beach over a different 12-month window.


Gross revenue and owner profit sit far apart. Full-service STR management typically runs 15% to 30% of gross booking revenue, and co-hosting typically 10% to 18%. On Surf City's $41,851 average, a 15% to 30% fee comes to roughly $6,300 to $12,600 a year, before cleaning, insurance, maintenance, lodging taxes, and platform charges. Our guide to what property managers charge walks through each line item.


Management also moves the top line. AirROI data across nine U.S. markets shows professionally managed listings earn 6% to 94% more annual revenue than self-hosted properties. That study is not Topsail-specific, and the spread is wide, so test it against your own calendar before you rely on it.


5. How Much Does Seasonality Swing Topsail Rental Income?


Seasonality is the predictable swing in demand across the calendar, and on Topsail Island it is steep. AirROI's Topsail Beach seasonal figures, shown below, put summer income at roughly four times winter income. July, June, and August are the busiest months for nights booked, and February and January are the quietest.


Topsail Beach period

Monthly revenue

Occupancy

ADR

June through August

$9,648

54.7%

$517

January, February, November

$2,422

25.2%

$325

December (trough)

$2,145

17.8%

Not reported


July is the peak month at $11,887 in monthly revenue per listing. That is the highest peak among the three towns, even though Topsail Beach has the fewest listings.


We treat the low season as a pricing problem. Shorter minimum stays and orphan-night discounts fill nights that a flat rate leaves empty. So does winter-focused listing copy. For projecting those months, see our occupancy forecast walkthrough.


Seasonal rental revenue analysis for Topsail Island vacation rental owners
An owner reviewing a seasonal revenue chart on a laptop at a kitchen island in a bright coastal beach house

6. Is Topsail Island Rental Supply Growing Faster Than Revenue?


Supply growth is the year-over-year increase in active listings, and on Topsail Island it outran revenue growth in every town. Listings grew between 51.8% and 63.0% across the three towns, while revenue per listing rose between 19.6% and 50.5%. North Topsail Beach came closest to keeping pace.


Visitor demand looks modest by comparison. According to the Topsail Area Chamber of Commerce, citing the annual study commissioned by Visit North Carolina, Pender County visitors spent $203.08 million in 2025, up 0.4% from 2024.


More homes sharing a slow-growing visitor base means guests compare more options. Listing quality then decides who gets the bookings: photos, furnishings, amenity mix, and review score. That is where design pays for itself, and these vacation rental interior design choices that pay off apply directly to a Topsail house competing against new inventory.


Avoid underwriting a purchase on last year's revenue growth. New supply can erode an average quickly, and a house that looks like every other four-bedroom will feel it first.


7. What Do Stay Length, Lead Time, and Property Mix Tell Owners?


Booking behavior describes how far ahead guests reserve and how long they stay, and Topsail Beach data points to long-lead group trips. AirROI reports a 5.6-night average stay and an 81-day average booking lead time. The property mix fits: 91.9% of Topsail Beach listings are houses, 42.5% have four bedrooms, and 64% accommodate at least eight guests.


An 81-day lead time means summer pricing decisions happen in winter and spring. If you leave July unpriced until June, you are selling into a calendar that has already filled.


Family and multi-generational groups drive this demand, so amenities need to match. We manage Surf City homes built around that pattern. South Shore Chateau is a 4-bedroom that sleeps 12 with an elevator, PS5 lounge, and pool table. Tide and Seek at Surf City is a 5-bedroom with an in-ground pool, hot tub, and fenced dog park. Pool season there runs mid-April through October.


You can see how we handle that segment on our Surf City management page. For the smallest of the three towns, our Topsail Beach management page covers the same approach.


Why Does Vacation Rental Market Data for Topsail Differ Between Reports?


Short-term rental market data is an estimate built from platform-derived listing records, so two reports can both be sound and still show different numbers. Two variables explain most gaps: the reporting window and the listing definition. The sample matters too. Matching those before comparing figures saves you from bad underwriting.


Report

Window and sample

Example figures

AirROI, three-town set

June 2025 to May 2026, all active listings in three towns

1,894 listings; 5.6-night stay; 81-day lead

AirROI island page

Its own 12-month window, whole island

1,865 homes; 5.1-night stay; about 70 days ahead; 38% occupancy

AirROI Topsail Beach page

A different 12-month window, one town

$38,025 revenue; $488 nightly rate; 36% booked nights


Compare towns using one source and one window, and read top-sample tables as a ceiling. When we run a revenue analysis for an owner, we check these inputs against the specific house: bedrooms, sleeps count, outdoor amenities, and location relative to the beach.


What Permits, Taxes, and Storm Risks Belong in Your Topsail Underwriting?


Rental compliance is the set of town and county obligations that apply before a Topsail property takes its first booking. State obligations apply too. Surf City and Topsail Beach sit in Pender County, and North Topsail Beach sits in Onslow County, so permit rules and occupancy tax collection can differ by town. Confirm current requirements with each town and county office before you list. Rates and rules change, so verify any figure you read in a market report at the official source.


Storm risk is the second cost. Hurricane season runs June to November, which overlaps July, the peak revenue month. Read your insurance policy for windstorm provisions and deductible terms before peak season, and set a cancellation policy you can enforce.


A storm-week cancellation costs you the booking and the turnover you already scheduled. Out-of-state owners should also have a local team that can secure the house and document its condition before and after a storm.


Frequently Asked Questions


Which vacation rental management companies on Topsail Island are most reliable for booking entire homes?


3 Putt Properties, LLC is a boutique short-term rental management company that manages whole-home rentals in Surf City and Topsail Island, handling pricing, cleaning and turnovers, guest communication, and listing optimization. When you compare any manager, ask for owner reporting and turnover verification. Also ask how they price gap nights and shoulder season.


How can I estimate rental income for my Topsail property?


Start with the town average from the snapshot table. Then adjust for bedroom count and guest capacity, along with amenities such as a pool or hot tub. Apply the seasonal curve, since summer carries most of the income, and subtract management fees, cleaning, insurance, taxes, and platform charges to reach a net figure.


How do I list my vacation rental on multiple portals without managing each one manually?


A channel manager syncs calendars, rates, and availability across Airbnb, Vrbo, and other platforms so one booking blocks the dates everywhere. That prevents double bookings and pricing mismatches. We handle channel management as part of our service, with human oversight of each platform's strategy.


How much does it cost to set up a vacation rental on Topsail Island?


Setup cost scales with bedroom count and guest capacity, because group-sized houses need more beds and linens. They also need more kitchen supplies and outdoor amenities. Budget separately for photography and for permits and tax registration. Any design work is its own line. We offer design consulting and source furnishing so spending ties back to expected rates.


Do Topsail Island rentals need a permit or pay occupancy tax?


Requirements depend on the town and county. Surf City and Topsail Beach are in Pender County, and North Topsail Beach is in Onslow County. Check current permit and lodging tax rules with the relevant town and county offices before listing, since rates and rules change.


How do Topsail rental rates compare to Wrightsville Beach?


A fair comparison needs the same data source and reporting window for both markets. Wrightsville Beach is in New Hanover County, a different permit and tax jurisdiction from the Topsail towns. We manage in both areas, and our Wrightsville Beach management page outlines how we approach it.


Conclusion


Vacation rental market data Topsail owners can defend starts with town-level averages from one source and one window. Occupancy in the mid to high thirties, nightly rates in the low to mid $400s, and a summer-heavy calendar describe the typical listing. Rising supply through 2026 makes design and pricing discipline the real differentiators. Early booking-window strategy matters just as much.


Underwrite with the averages and treat top-sample months as upside. Verify permits and taxes with each town and county. If you want to see how these numbers play out for your Topsail property, 3 Putt Properties, LLC runs a straightforward revenue conversation covering pricing, turnovers, and listing strategy. Reach out through our website to start.


Written by Eric McCarty, Found, CEO at 3 Putt Properties, LLC


Content powered by inkSTR.co


Comments


bottom of page